Main Page Contact Register Log In


Calling what happened in Egypt a Western political voting system is a bit like saying that communist countries that have elections have "Western political voting system". It's misleading.
The Muslim Brotherhood wasn't intend on playing within the rules on democracy. It wasn't trying to join existing political organisations.
The way the dealt with the situation was a major strategic blunder and the lost a lot in Egypt because of it.

Where does Voice of Ra got the idea of political change through getting influence in institutions?
It's the theory of political change of democratic socialism. While Marx said that political change can never happen through elections but only through revolution democratic socialism proclaims that it works well through.

What's the theory of political change of Salafism? You create an alternative system. Muslims don't integrate themselves into the state. They solve their disputes with each other in Sharia courts. Over times the state get weaker. It can't serve it's basic functions while the local Muslim community can provide the roles of the state for their members. That's what Sayyid Qutb lays out in Milestones.

But why do I say Salafi's don't like voting?

To excerpt a passage from Milestones:
Our first step will be to raise ourselves above the Jahili society, and all its values and concepts. We will not change our own values and concepts either more or
less to make a bargain with this Jahili society. Never! Even if we were on
different roads, and if we take even one step in its company, we will lose our
goal entirely and lose our way as well.


Here's one article article:

One of them, Abed Shehadeh, leader of the Salafi Jihadi movement in Jordan, ruled this week that democracy in its concept as "ruling of the people by the people" and "should be forbidden in Islam." [...] he urged Jordanians to boycott the elections because "choosing legislators other than Allah is forbidden."


The splendid article on What ISIS wants in the Atlantic contains a paragraph saying:
But Zarqawi and the state he spawned take the position that many other acts can remove a Muslim from Islam. These include, in certain cases, selling alcohol or drugs, wearing Western clothes or shaving one’s beard, voting in an election—even for a Muslim candidate—and being lax about calling other people apostates.


According to Daesh voting in an election makes a Muslim an apostate and there a death penalty for being an apostate. These attacks in Paris where Daesh fault but the attacks on people drawing Mohammed weren't. Daesh has a specific agenda with their caliphate that I don't want to go into here.

Why attack cartoonists? The goal is to radicalize Western Muslims. The Salafi's want to have them live the Muslim live according to the Sharia instead of having Muslims integrate themselves into Western society and live according to Western laws. Justifying killing the cartoonists is a lot easier to justify than killing civilians.