OMNILIBRIUM
  Rational Discussion of Controversial Topics


GO TO THE MAIN THREAD Sort By:


ChristianKl 29 January 2016 02:54 AM
61%

In case of the UK, it seems that the Scots are actually in a more privileged position than the English.
For some values of "privileged" that might be true. Scotland has more oil. On the other hand the UK get's ruled from London, mostly by the English.

stars0
Reply


melian 29 January 2016 06:11 AM
70%

I was referring to the fact that Scots get considerable autonomy in deciding their own matters, while getting more than an equal vote in general elections (the average size of constituencies in Wales is 56,628 and in Scotland 65,475, whereas the average size in England is 71,858).

stars0
Reply


ChristianKl 7 February 2016 02:35 AM
62%

You can say the same thing of the EU and yet, it's publically said that big countries like Germany control the EU. The doesn't even get ruled via Berlin the way the UK get's ruled via London.

In the UK permanent secretary of a department is a role of a civil servants. In the Germany that's each minister makes political appointment for his "Staatssekretär" (equivalent to the UK's permanent secretary). In the US a new administration can even change out more people in the burocracy.

This results in the situation in the UK that get's portraid in "Yes, Prime Minister" where the civil servants residing in London have enormous power.

You have an elite where a stereotypical Humphrey considers there to be two universities in the UK: Oxford and Cambridge. Maybe also the London School of Economics
Humphrey is a fictional character but the producers of the show did a lot of real research.

stars0
Reply